Skip to main content

How to Do Fast Prototyping Manufacturing? Choose a Right Tool First!

What tools should be chosen to fast prototyping manufacturing has long been a subject of debate. The only option was Visio in the earlier time; now some other tools, such as Axure, Mockplus, OmniGraffle and Adobe Creative Suite, are increasingly flourishing and influential; moreover, we designers also have a lot of choices in different segments, such as Balsamiq, Lucidchart, Google Drive and other online tools, as well as XMind, Mindmanager, MindNode and other mindmap tools. So which is the best prototyping tool?

Comparison

In the process of practical usage, due to different specific project phases, platform characteristics and audiences, no tools gets the unanimous approval of the designers, and each one has its advantages and disadvantages. Based on my personal experience, I made a comparison among several common tools.

Here is a detailed description of the pros and cons of each software.

comparison

1.Adobe


The capability to use Photoshop is regarded as one of the designer's special skills. It can be theoretically used to make any graphics. However, it costs a little more in making and modifying interactive prototypes; it is unable to flexibly dispose image layers and components; it has certain limitations of its performance and template base; when using Photoshop, designers may untimely get trapped in detail discussion and forget their original intention. Hence, Photoshop is not the ideal choice in interaction design. Surely it can be an intuitionistic way when designers originally intend to make a high-fidelity demo.

Illustrator is slightly good at vector processing. When using Illustrator, designers are enabled to avoid being obsessed with canvas sizes and image layers. It has a large template library to support fast prototyping manufacturing, but it inherit the consistent characteristics of Adobe series that strong and complete functions result in cumbersome operation, so it’s inefficient to use it to do prototyping.

In contrast, Fireworks has a simpler interface and have strengths in image layer processing. Especially, its editable PNG files contain image layers and vector information, which ensure the coherence of the documents. Hence it is favored by many design teams and regarded as the best choice of interaction output tools. However, Adobe doesn’t offer much support to Fireworks and it is even excluded by the newest Adobe CC series. In this situation, Fireworks has limited room for improvement.

2.Mockplus


Fast Interaction

The interaction design in Mockplus is totally visible, that is, WYSIWYG. With a simple drag-and-drop an interactive prototype can be built effortlessly. A set of pre-designed components, including pop-up panel, stack panel, scroll box, sliding drawer and image carousel, allow you to create fully interactions faster and easier.

Fast Designing

Mockplus encapsulates more than 3,000 icons and nearly 200 components. Just drag these components into the canvas for a combination and your app ideas can be demonstrated by a prototype within few minutes. No more efforts will be spent on making a component and you can focus on design itself.

Fast Previewing

Scan the generated QR code to preview prototypes on the actual device instantly, no USB cable required. Publish the project to cloud and you will get a shareable web link that can be sent to co-workers & clients. It's also possible to export to HTML offline.

Fast Learning

Mockplus help you focus on design itself rather than the tool. You can get started easily without the risk of becoming the tool's slave investing a lot of time and money on learning and training. With Mockplus, you don’t need to worry about programming knowledge anymore, let alone coding. You can easily master this tool by watching its tutorials. Hence Mockplus is a good choice to do rapid prototyping.

mockplus

3.Keynote


As a non-professional drawing tool, making use of Keynote/PPT to draw interaction drafts is a little more indirect path to reach the goal. Its abundant interaction actions and simple use flows fully meet the needs of interaction demonstration and fast prototyping manufacturing. It has obvious merits and demerits: it has few templates; it’s time and energy-consuming to use it without the assistance of other tools.

Axure is known as a must for internet product managers. It has distinct advantages: its operative complexity is between those of Keynote/PPT and Adobe series; it has a full web control library which can be used to rapidly make web prototypes by direct drag and drop; its abundant dynamic panels can be used to simulate the complex effects of various interactions; after a prototype is exported as a HTML, the information architecture and the process of page skip can be more accurately demonstrated.

However, due to inadequate support to mobile prototypes, Axure can’t export the files that can be demonstrated on mobile terminals. Only the demonstration of information structures and page logic is supported. It lacks the diversity in the processing of shape styles, a lot of details can not be preserved really well and hence the wireframes made by it are mostly not good-looking.

4.OmniGraffle


OmniGraffle is a good prototyping tool for Mac, and can be used to draw general charts, tree structures, flowcharts, page choreography, etc. You can have a try to use it to make a movie script plan and draw a company's organizational structure, or even regard it as PowerPoint to show a project. Therefore you can do fast prototyping manufacturing through this tool.

With the use of a lot of OS X’s vanilla drawing functions, Omnigraffle only supports Mac / iPad. It has a lot of similarities with Visio in many aspects; even the name of the "Graffle" are created corresponding to "Visio". Although in the web interaction it has not as many components as Axure, and its support to the mobile platforms is not as good as some rising stars (such as Briefs and Fluidui), but it can contend with the other competitors because of its rich template base, ease of use and so many intimate details.

The above tools are able to cover most user scenarios. Yet tools are only an extension of paper and pen. With the mastery of one of these tools, we designers should continue to try new tools, which can not only find more valuable techniques to speed up the design pace, but also enhance the ability to understand our own weaknesses. Use these tools conjunctively so thatdo fast prototyping manufacturing and ideas will not be limited by tools, and strive to become a full stack designer.

Read more:

Author: Shang
Translator: Chloe
Original website: ISUX
Original link: http://isux.tencent.com/speed-up-wireframing.html

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Top 15 UX/UI Designers You Should Follow to Flow Out Inspiration in 2018

As is known, design is a rather broad and hard-to-define term. There are a wealth of different responsibilities encompassed by the term designer and design-related roles which have been existing in a wide range of areas, varying from print (publications and magazine) to industrial design (furniture and cars). With new design roles emerging in the industry, job titles like UX/UI designers seem to be confusing for both experienced and uninitiated designers. Before diving deeper, let’s have a quick look on the difference between UX and UI terms. User Experience (UX) designis a concept that has many dimensions and primarily concerned with how the product will feel. To solve a specific user problem, a UX designer will explore many different approaches, as any given design problem doesn’t have one single right answer. By identifying verbal/non-verbal stumbling blocks, UX designers refine and iterate to make the “best” user experience. Here is how Laura Klein (the author of UX for Lean Start…

13 Must-Have UX Tools for Designers

What are the UX design tools you use to create flowcharts? What are the best tools for wireframingprototypinguser testinginteraction design or team collaboration? There are an overwhelming number of UX tools out there, and finding the best can be mind-boggling. If you’re looking for UX design tools and UX wireframe tools to make your life easier, this post is written specifically for you. To help you create apps/websites with high productivity, we explore 13 amazing UX tools and best prototyping tools you should have for 2017. UX tools for mind mapping: MindManager
A mind map is a diagram used to visually organize information. It is a great way to brainstorm, make a plan, or turn ideas into the steps needed to make it real. MindManager is one of the best mind mapping software application developed by Mindjet. The digital mind maps can be used a “virtual whiteboard” for brainstorming, managing and planning projects, compiling research, organizing large amounts of information, an…

Professional UX Design Approaches for Building The Best Website

Building a website through UX design approaches is very much like painting or sculptural art, they all take patience, foresight, aesthetics ability, creativity and perception of details. Generally, the website you design represents your company, it needs to be stunning and breathtaking. If you look deeper into the aspects of website building, you can find some core UX features that outstanding websites share. By analyzing the top design trends, we may accurately trace out four major professional UX design methods for website building. 1. Streamlined Navigation By saying “Streamlined Navigation”, I do not only refer to the navigation bar but all others navigations on a larger scale. Not to mention the great ones, a standard website also needs to be of high usability. Besides that, the speed and accuracy of loading are of decisive significance as well. In professional UX principles, the typography should be carefully organized to ensure the best user experience. Links should be highly …